The Reeler

Recent Comments


A Girl and a Gun
Ain't It Cool News
Alliance of Women Film Journalists
Anne Thompson
Art Fag City
Better Than Fudge
Big Picture Big Sound
Bitter Cinema
Blank Screen
Brian Flemming
Bright Lights
Celluloid Eyes
Chutry Experiment, The
Cinema Confidential
Cinema Eye
Coming Soon
Cool Cinema Trash
Cyndi Greening
Dark Horizons
Drew's Blog-O-Rama
Esoteric Rabbit
Film Detail
Film Experience, The
Film Journal, The
Film Journey
Film Stew
Film Rotation
GreenCine Daily
Hacking Netflix
Hammer to Nail
High Sign, The
Hollywood Elsewhere
House Next Door, The
IFC Blog, The
In the Company of Glenn
IndieScene Movie Marketing Blog
indieWIRE Blogs
Jay's Movie Blog
JoBlo's Movie Emporium
Kaiju Shakedown
Like Anna Karina's Sweater
Last Night with Riviera
Light Sleeper
Long Pauses
Masters of Cinema
Matt Zoller Seitz
Midnight Eye
Milk Plus
Mind Jack
Movie Blog, The
Movie City Indie
Movie Hole, The
Movie Poop Shoot
New York Cool
NY Post Movie Blog
News of the Dead
No More Marriages!
Notes From Underdog
Out of Focus
Persistence of Vision
Queer Film Review
Reel Roundtable
Screen Rush
Screener (Film Journal Int.)
Screening the Past
Self-Styled Siren
Short Sheet, The
Slant Magazine
Slant Magazine Blog
Still in Motion
Stranger Song, The
They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
Tisch Film Review
Vince Keenan
World Film (at
You Know, For Film

The Reeler Blog

Coming Soon: "Shredding the Envelope" (Or Something)

If you listen close, you'll hear me alternately clapping and sobbing over the tag-team job Noel Murray and Scott Tobias lay on Oscar prognosticators over at The A.V. Club. In deconstructing the mythos of the Academy Awards' mass appeal, the authors evoke the same sober outrage that I've been nurturing myself since my first awards-season trial last year -- something like helplessness, but with... momentum:

TOBIAS: Taste dictates these assessments to a certain degree, but when a film gets deemed "Oscar-worthy," it's the furthest thing from critical advocacy. All it means is that a particular film has qualities that Oscar voters traditionally find attractive -- a middlebrow sense of grandeur, a message that seems risky without actually being provocative, name stars emoting like crazy, and the potential for at least modest success at the box office. If the OPs have any effect on the process, it's really to enforce (rather than challenge) the status quo: Instead of doing something good for humanity, like asking voters to consider some movie or performance that really moved them, they're filtering everything they see for the same "Oscar-worthy" qualities that have made the awards such a useless barometer for cinematic excellence throughout history. ...
MURRAY: Anyway, there's a distressing unanimity to what the OPs write about. Eventually, it all narrows down to the same dozen or so films, judged not so much on what they mean to the writer, but on what they might mean to a group of people not even in the screening room. And the only question in film criticism more pernicious than "Will audiences like it?" is "What will the Academy think?"

Indeed, we face an accountability vacuum that is destroying cinema and must be seriously addressed. So that's it -- as if this site weren't out-of-control enough, I'm adding a new feature: From here on out, The Reeler is watching the watchers. Working title: Shredding the Envelope. "But what does this have to do with New York cinema," you ask? Good question at face value, but think of it this way: Who else is going to do it? We can just outrun Academy fever with a 3,000-mile head start, and we've got the best concentration of film and media critical minds on the planet. Not that we're necessarily anti-Oscar or anything; we're just anti-Oscar's dick in our mouths. I mean, the time you spend reading Tom O'Neil and David Poland would be so much better spent catching up on the masterpiece you might be missing around the corner (to paraphrase Reid Rosefelt), don't you think?

So look for that -- eventually. Send tips, hints and suggestions, and we'll get right to business.

Posted at November 17, 2006 12:00 PM

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Search The Reeler
Join the Mailing List

RSS Feed


Send a Tip